Simon Cowell slammed for brutal fat-shaming as old X Factor clip resurfaces

It turns out she was actually pregnant

We know Simon Cowell is not a man to mince his words. But this old clip from 2004 has shocked even die-hard fans, as it shows him shaming an X Factor contestant over her weight.

The talent show judge – along with his co-stars Louis Walsh and Sharon Osbourne – were labelled “awful” and “harsh” after telling a pregnant woman to “go on a diet”.

x factor 2004
The three judges told her to go on a diet (Credit: ITV)

The original video shows Samantha auditioning with a heartfelt rendition of Mariah Carey’s Hero.

She tells the camera: “I got married a week on Saturday. I’m also supposed to be on our honeymoon in Barbados at the minute, but we cancelled it so I could come and do this!

“If I don’t get through, I will be absolutely gutted because it means absolutely everything to me.”

x factor 2004
Samantha said she’d do anything to get through (Credit: ITV)

Simon, now 59, originally told her: “I like you.” But after she sang, he told her: “You sound nice, but you look like a shop girl. That’s the problem.”

She replied: “OK. That’s something can be worked on.” And he cuttingly told her: “Well, it’s a lot of work.”

Louis added: “I think you should have gone on your honeymoon. I really do. It’s nothing special, Simon.” He then called her: “Mission impossible.”

x factor 2004 simon cowell
Back in 2004, Mr Nasty was truly nasty (Credit: ITV)

Samantha then said: “I know what you’re saying” and the music mogul asked: “What are we saying?” She looked embarrassed as she told him: “That I’m overweight.” He responded: “You are, you really are.”

Sharon, 66, told her she had a “lovely face, and a lovely voice.” But she added: “Missus, go on a diet.”

x factor 2004 simon cowell
Sharon said she had a lovely face (Credit: ITV)

Almost the most shocking part is that Samantha ended up THANKING the judges, when they reluctantly put her through to the next stage – on the condition she lose weight.

And in a shocking second clip, we saw Samantha admitting to presenter Kate Thornton that she was actually seven months pregnant!

x factor 2004 sharon osbourne
Sharon put her through on the condition she go on a diet (Credit: ITV)

While cradling her bump, she said: “[I’m] nearly seven months. At the end of the day, I’m pregnant. There’s nothing I can do about it. So I’m going to try and go as far as I can, the way I am.”

Read more: Dawn French reignites fierce scone debate on Twitter

Social media exploded over the clip, with most blasting the judges for their unforgivable comments.

x factor 2004 simon cowell
Samantha skipped her honeymoon to audition (Credit: ITV)

One wrote: “I CANNOT BELIEVE HOW HARSH THEY USED TO BE ON THE X FACTOR. This poor woman 😩 Imagine the uproar if they said this now.”

A second commented: “Wow!! Three of the biggest judges on #XFactor fat shaming a girl back in 2004 – what the hell gives you [the right] #simoncowell #sharonosbourne #louiswalsh to tell a person they are fat & go on a diet? Should be ashamed of yourselves.”

A third said: “And they wonder why girls worry about their weight.”

Even EastEnders actress Danniella Westbrook waded into the conversation, tweeting: “Awful, girl was stunning I thought x.”

Some others defended the judges, with one tweeting: “I don’t feel shock but for today’s double standards. Back then at least people were honest enough to admit that a pop star has to meet idiotic beauty standards. Nowadays they still do but have to pretend as if they thought being fat is good and ok…”

Another said: “What? Like you thought he was a good person?”

A third wrote: “Sadly this is / was the harsh reality of the music industry back then and probably still is in some places – I’m not shocked at this at all.”

In an extra twist to the story, Twitter user Russell – who originally posted the old clip – claims to have received a message from Samantha herself.

In the message, she apparently wrote: “You want to let everyone know I’m alive and kicking!! A friend sent me the link today so joined twitter to have a read!! It was brutal looking back but like a good wine I got better with age!!!”

(Credit: samanthareay3 Twitter)
14 years later and Samantha is still beautiful (Credit: samanthareay3 Twitter)

She also tweeted that she had been on “the diet of life” and posted a picture of herself now, slimmer, with darker hair.

Read more: James Jordan takes on MORE ice in freezing Cryotherapy treatment!

We’d clearly forgotten how harsh the judges could be. Maybe age has softened them all up?

Are you shocked by Simon’s comments? Leave us a comment on our Facebook page @EntertainmentDailyFix and let us know what you think.

Related Topics